Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net

Carl Bildt, Swedish MFA. Photo by Per Dahl / Informationsföreningen. CC, FlickR (linked).

Sweden’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Carl Bildt, has an op-ed piece today in the printed newspaper Expressen where he criticizes some of Sweden’s most known activists for not understanding the politics of the Net. In doing this, he shows his bright censorship colors as he derides the protection of fundamental rights as “anarchy”.

In this piece, he attacks Måns Adler (founder of Bambuser), Christopher Kullenberg (Intensifier at Telecomix), and Anna Troberg (leader of the Swedish Pirate Party) and claims that they don’t understand the Net. That’s a tall order. A tall order indeed. I’m willing to bet that these three individuals are a whole lot more known in the world for their understanding of the Net than Mr. Bildt is. As we can see from his arguments, this becomes painfully obvious: the ego of Mr. Bildt is writing checks that his logic and understanding are unable to cash.

Mr. Bildt is trying to distinguish “good flows” from “bad flows” on the net, wanting to safeguard the former but prevent the latter. With considerable derision, he labels a lack of such governmental control as “anarchy”. However, as the attacked people have tried to point out to the Swedish minister, it is not possible to harm unwanted activities without harming wanted activities as well. You can technically safeguard the right to communicate in private, and what people choose to use that for depends on the people.

It is important to understand that somebody’s activity on the net is one of the most revealing pieces of information you can get about an individual: looking at somebody’s net activity is as close as we have ever come to mind reading. Therefore, dividing this activity into “lawful” and “illegal” is also the closest we have come to thoughtcrime.

Mr. Bildt is painfully defending his idea of censorship by pointing out that heresy was a crime before World War II, so censorship now should be no different (!!). This is where it stops being logical and I become angry at having people in charge who are not even making an effort.

The Swedish administration recently passed a general wiretapping law where a governmental agency wiretaps all net traffic that happens to cross the borders, which you never know if yours will. It puts the MFA’s efforts into perspective: his pretend shining armor is certainly tainted and in need of a bit of polishing, and any statement from this administration about safeguarding liberties on the net simply lacks credibility.

As Niklas Dougherty writes, the key problem with Mr. Bildt’s reasoning is that he is unable (or unwilling) to distinguish freedom of expression from freedom of information. Freedom of expression can indeed have some limits, though always post facto. The most famous example is that you can’t shout Fire! in a crowded theater, but there are plenty of other examples: you can’t distribute military secrets, people’s medical records, et cetera.

However, the freedom of information is a different beast. This is the freedom to seek, fetch and research information and the expressions of other human beings unfettered, and has nothing to do with sending a message to any other human being. The freedom of information must be absolutely unhindered, with no exceptions. None. Not one. If you are cracking down on this, you are interfering with private correspondence and the right to partake of the ideas of others. Such behavior would also in sharp violation of the European Convention on Human Rights (article 8).

It would not be the first time this administration had failed to uphold fundamental constitutional rights.

Rick Falkvinge

Rick is the founder of the first Pirate Party and a low-altitude motorcycle pilot.

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published.

Since I'm not a robot spammer I'm also answering this easy question:

Discussion

  1. on #infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://goo.gl/fb/ZBfzw

  2. Johanna Drott (@sargoth)

    RT @Falkvinge: on #infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://goo.gl/fb/ZBfzw

  3. Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net, Justifies With Heresy Laws http://is.gd/vPxwYF #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  4. Falkvinge on Infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net:
    Sweden’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Carl Bil… http://tinyurl.com/4mj3pwb

  5. Arvid Falk (@arvidf)

    RT @Falkvinge: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net, Justifies With Heresy Laws http://is.gd/vPxwYF #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  6. Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net:
    Sweden’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Carl Bildt, has an op-ed piece today in… http://bit.ly/hFoRx9

  7. Christer

    Excellent post, Rick!

  8. RT @Falkvinge: on #infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://goo.gl/fb/ZBfzw

  9. jan lindbom (@gotlandsandra)

    Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net – Falkvinge on Infopolicy http://ow.ly/44oNZ

  10. GERSSa (@GERSSa)

    Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net – Falkvinge on Infopolicy http://ow.ly/44oNT

  11. Glyn Moody (@glynmoody)

    Swedish Minister of Foreign Affairs Cracking Down On Net – http://bit.ly/fid0Dg sad to see #sweden going down #censorship route too

  12. Leanne O'Donnell (@lods1211)

    Swedish Foreign Affairs Min. "unable to distinguish freedom of expression from freedom of information" http://bit.ly/fid0Dg via @glynmoody

  13. RT @Falkvinge: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net, Justifies With Heresy Laws http://is.gd/vPxwYF #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  14. Uno Hansson

    “… People often think that if they can just show the world how terrible an opponent is, they’ll be able to get rid of the opponent. That’s nonsense…”

    Read more: http://www.utne.com/Politics/Gene-Sharp-Interview-Power-of-Nonviolence.aspx?page=3#ixzz1FCvy3NnN

  15. Uno Hansson

    Innan jag postade så glömde jag skriva att detta tror tydligen Carl Bildt m.fl.

  16. ©Britt (@2Britt)

    RT @Falkvinge: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net, Justifies With Heresy Laws http://is.gd/vPxwYF #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  17. Anders Andersson (@SM5POR)

    RT @glynmoody: Swedish Minister of Foreign Affairs Cracking Down On Net – http://bit.ly/fid0Dg sad to see #sweden going down #censorship route too

  18. Jose Murilo (@josemurilo)

    RT @glynmoody: Swedish Minister of Foreign Affairs Cracking Down On Net – http://bit.ly/fid0Dg sad to see #sweden going down #censorship route too

  19. Falkvinge on Infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net – http://bit.ly/idLB21

  20. RT @glynmoody Swedish Minister Cracking Down On Net – http://bit.ly/fid0Dg << hope it’s just this guy talking to curry favor with corps

  21. Ann Markström (@Annoula64)

    RT @piratbloggar: Falkvinge on Infopolicy: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net:
    Sweden’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Carl Bil… http://tinyurl.com/4mj3pwb

  22. RT @Falkvinge: Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net, Justifies With Heresy Laws http://is.gd/vPxwYF #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  23. !!! Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://bit.ly/ijwk8Z

  24. RT @falkvinge Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://is.gd/r4YDxM #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  25. RT @urbansundstrom: RT @falkvinge Swedish MFA Cracking Down On Net http://is.gd/r4YDxM #carlbildt #censorship #fra #infopolicy

  26. Nelson Cruz

    Protecting internet freedom means protecting what you don’t like as much as what you do like. Same as freedom of speech. Otherwise we become no different from china and others like it, not matter how much democratic we call ourselves.

arrow