• Flattr FoI: 
Falkvinge &Co. on Infopolicy
BEFORE-FALKVINGE-IF-ANY FALKVINGE &CO. ON
INFOPOLICY
Falkvinge on Infopolicy - Home
»
Photo from Wroclaw, Poland

On Panel in Wroclaw, Poland

1

Copyright Monopoly

Copyright Monopoly

Yesterday, I was in a panel on the European Culture Congress here in Wroclaw, Poland. The title was Wikianarchy, and the topic — as usual — the copyright monopoly.

Happily, there was no representative from the copyright industry there to dish out their usual fundamentalist views, calling anybody who questioned them a heretic and expecting that to settle the discussion. Rather, the panel (recorded video not up yet) consisted of five people who were gradually more sceptical of the copyright monopoly — and I wasn’t even the most sceptical one.

The first was an executive from a large, well-known TV channel. His solution was to let all the copyright monopoly holders decide how others were allowed to distribute their works.

The second, a professor from Barcelona, opposed this wildly. “That attitude of denial is what got us here in the first place.” Instead, she proposed making the ISPs liable for what they transmit — abolishing the messenger immunity — and even though the monopoly holders would not have a say whether their works were transmitted, she still insisted on having ISP-level automated censorship, preventing anybody from transmitting without authorization. She was also in favor of so-called cultural flatrate, which is (also) a terrible idea.

She insisted that this had nothing to do with limiting free speech. It’s been a long time since I saw an audience so openly hostile to a panelist — several in the audience stood up and told her in agitated voices how wrong she was on this point.

The third was also a professor, but from Poland. He had a more cautionary approach, describing the current laws as problematic, and saying plainly that “more copyright doesn’t work, we all know that”.

I was fourth. My approach for this panel was that I don’t care if some people don’t make money the way they want, entrepreneurs still don’t get to dismantle civil liberties to boost their profits. (I wrote a column for TorrentFreak on the topic, which can be found here.) I outlined that our parents could send letters without being tracked and the mailman was never responsible for them, even if directly illegal; I was applauded when I pointed out that it is perfectly reasonable to demand that our children have the same rights as our parents and grandparents.

When our parents sent a letter in the mail, nobody was allowed to open it to check if it contained a copied poem, which would infringe on the copyright monopoly. When our parents sent a letter in the mail, they and they alone determined if they identified themselves as sender on the outside of the envelope, inside the envelope, or not at all. When our parents sent a letter in the mail, the mailman was never held responsible for the contents of that letter, regardless of if the contents infringed a particular copyright monopoly or were even downright illegal.

(On this, the first professor interrupted and pointed out that the mailman doesn’t make money on distributing the letters. I have no idea how she came to that conclusion; they aren’t exactly volunteers.)

The fifth person was a professor from Amsterdam, who was the most outspoken of all, claiming that the copyright monopoly is censorship, pure and simple, as it prevents art from being created and songs from being sung. While he is formally right about this, I found the rhetoric somewhat weak — saying this doesn’t make people directly understand why the copyright monopoly harms society, unless you’ve already done quite a bit of thinking on the subject. It doesn’t get the penny to drop. Still, it was nice to see that I was not the most hardline opposer of the monopoly.

The conference as such (European Culture Congress) was huge — it is part of the Polish EU presidency and there were ministers and security at ridiculous levels everywhere. This panel was held in a room for 800 people, and was moderated by Ruben Maes, who handled the diverging viewpoints and engaged the audience beautifully.

You've read the whole article. Why not subscribe to the RSS flow using your favorite reader, or even have articles delivered by mail?

About The Author: Rick Falkvinge

Rick is the founder of the first Pirate Party and is a political evangelist, traveling around Europe and the world to talk and write about ideas of a sensible information policy. He has a tech entrepreneur background and loves whisky.

Liked This?

By participating in the discussion and posting here, you are placing your contribution in the public domain (CC0). If you are quoting somebody else, credit them.

Contributors take own responsibility for their comments.

1

  1. 1

    Unless the professor from Amsterdam has changed his tune — see http://gondwanaland.com/mlog/2005/10/18/imagine-usufruct/ — there wasn’t a total abolitionist represented. Sad.

Add a Comment

− 1 = 7  

On Facebook

Popular Articles

Adobe the leech - original photo by OakleyOriginals on Flickr
164

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Money cut into pieces - Photo by Flickr user Tax Credits
76

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Librep July 12 frame
32

Civil Liberties

Civil Liberties

colorblindflag
22

United States – Zacqary Adam Xeper

United States – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Screenshot from Librep-2014-08-10-take1.mp4
4

Civil Liberties

Civil Liberties

More in Copyright Monopoly

Bottles of Snake Oil - Photo by Jagrap on Flickr
29

Copyright Monopoly – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Copyright Monopoly – Zacqary Adam Xeper

photo_10071_20090418-646x363
71

Copyright Monopoly – David Collier-Brown

Copyright Monopoly – David Collier-Brown

le_tresor_rackham_le_rouge_1280x1024
11

Copyright Monopoly – Lionel Dricot

Copyright Monopoly – Lionel Dricot

Books before copyright
99

Copyright Monopoly – Johnny Olsson

Copyright Monopoly – Johnny Olsson

Other Recent Headlines

peter_sunde_0237
12

Swarm Economy – Lionel Dricot

Swarm Economy – Lionel Dricot

solarroad
15

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

European Parliament
70

Pirate Parties

Pirate Parties

Burned book
35

Civil Liberties – Henrik Alexandersson

Civil Liberties – Henrik Alexandersson

NSA Seal Holding the Heartbleed Logo
40

Infrastructure – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Infrastructure – Zacqary Adam Xeper

PPEU founding in European Parliament, March 21, 2014.
17

Pirate Parties

Pirate Parties

About The Author

Rick is the founder of the first Pirate Party and is a political evangelist, traveling around Europe and the world to talk and write about ideas of a sensible information policy. He has a tech entrepreneur background and loves whisky.

More On Infopolicy

Bitcoin concept by Antanacoins. CC-By-SA, Flickr.
42

Cryptocurrency – Charlie Shrem

Cryptocurrency – Charlie Shrem

facebook
12

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

523377_63619557
4

Infopolicy – Henrik Brändén

Infopolicy – Henrik Brändén

National_Security_Agency_headquarters,_Fort_Meade,_Maryland_public_domain_image
150

Infopolicy – Christian Engström

Infopolicy – Christian Engström

"God Hates Signs" next to "God Hates Fags" protesters
8

Freedom of Speech – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Freedom of Speech – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Many different currencies - CC photo by epSos.de
45

Diversity – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Diversity – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Valve mechanism
92

Freedom of Speech

Freedom of Speech

Collaborative whiteboard at OuiShare 2012, full of wonderful ideas for venture capitalists to ruin - photo by Natalie Ortiz
15

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Swarm Economy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Border Patrol In Montana
25

Activism – Travis McCrea

Activism – Travis McCrea

Spices - Marrakech 09 Souks
58

Swarm Economy

Swarm Economy

Screen Shot 2013-06-27 at 7.23.12 PM
33

Copyright Monopoly – Travis McCrea

Copyright Monopoly – Travis McCrea

An Ouya console and controller
15

Infopolicy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Infopolicy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Smári McCarthy
36

Privacy – Christian Engström

Privacy – Christian Engström

1984-ish poster from London's Public Transport
8

Privacy – Loz Kaye

Privacy – Loz Kaye

Man slamming his head on a desk in frustration - CC photo by Flickr user mbshane
36

Privacy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

Privacy – Zacqary Adam Xeper

This publication is protected under the Constitution of the Kingdom of Sweden. Any problem you have with this publication remains exclusively yours. Accountable publisher: Rick Falkvinge.
All text on this site is Public Domain / CC0 unless specifically noted and credited otherwise. Copy, remix, and inspire. (Troll policy.)
Log in | Original theme design by Gabfire themes (heavily modified)