Analog Equivalent Rights (12/21): Our parents bought things untracked, their footsteps in store weren’t recorded

In the last article, we focused on how people are tracked today when using credit cards instead of cash. But few pay attention to the fact that we’re tracked when using cash today, too.

Few people pay attention to the little sign on the revolving door on Schiphol Airport in Amsterdam, Netherlands. It says that wi-fi and bluetooth tracking of every single individual is taking place in the airport.

What sets Schiphol Airport apart isn’t that they track individual people’s movements to the sub-footstep level in a commercial area. (It’s for commercial purposes, not security purposes.) No, what sets Schiphol apart is that they bother to tell people about it. (The Netherlands tend to take privacy seriously, as does Germany, and for the same reason.)

Locator beacons are practically a standard in bigger commercial areas now. They ping your phone using wi-fi and bluetooth, and using signal strength triangulation, a grid of locator beacons is able to show how every single individual is moving in realtime at the sub-footstep level. This is used to “optimize marketing” — in other words, find ways to trick people’s brains to spend resources they otherwise wouldn’t have. Our own loss of privacy is being turned against us, as it always is.

Where do people stop for a while, what catches their attention, what doesn’t catch their attention, what’s a roadblock for more sales?

These are legitimate questions. However, taking away people’s privacy in order to answer those questions is not a legitimate method to answer them.

This kind of mass individual tracking has even been deployed at city levels, which happened in complete silence until the Privacy Oversight Board of a remote government sounded the alarms. The city of Västerås got the green light to continue tracking once some formal criteria were met.

Yes, this kind of people tracking is documented to have been already rolled out citywide in at least one small city in a remote part of the world (Västerås, Sweden). With the government’s Privacy Oversight Board having shrugged and said “fine, whatever”, don’t expect this to stay in the small town of Västerås. Correction, wrong tense: don’t expect it to have stayed in just Västerås, where it was greenlit three years ago.

Our analog parents had the ability to walk around untracked in the city and street of their choice, without it being used or held against them. It’s not unreasonable that our digital children should have the same ability.

There’s one other way to buy things with cash which avoids this kind of tracking, and that’s paying cash-on-delivery when ordering something online or over the phone to your door — in which case your purchase is also logged and recorded, just in another type of system.

This isn’t only used against the ordinary citizen for marketing purposes, of course. It’s used against the ordinary citizen for every conceivable purpose. But we’ll be returning to that in a later article in the series.

Privacy remains your own responsibility.

Syndicated Article
This article was previously published at Private Internet Access..

Rick Falkvinge

Rick is the founder of the first Pirate Party and a low-altitude motorcycle pilot. He lives on Alexanderplatz in Berlin, Germany, roasts his own coffee, and as of right now (2019-2020) is taking a little break.


  1. Anonymous

    A mobile phone isn’t part of a human body, is it? The article seems to suggest it is.

    1. Scary Devil Monastery

      “A mobile phone isn’t part of a human body, is it? The article seems to suggest it is.”

      No, it is not a part of your body. The same way your clothes, wallet, watch and your house keys aren’t.

      It’s simply the communications device used for a VERY significant proportion of your communication with other citizens.
      Put that item under permanent surveillance and in effect the government (or whoever else can be bothered) has clipped a camera to your person, wallet, or house keys. The best you can expect is to be told that this has been done.

      And this is something which is still very dangerous since in very real terms democracy relies on government NOT being able to do this except under circumstances which are invoked by penal law, due suspicion, and a warrant.

  2. Colin

    I knew I was right not to have a mobile phone!

  3. John

    Fascinating article. with great information.

  4. shivi


  5. Vivek Jazz

    Thank you very much to sharing this post.

  6. Nieomi

    Great Article

  7. happy wheels

    Fascinating article. with great information.

  8. Norton Antivirus Phone Number

    I am very grateful you did share your knowledge here. It is an excellent post Thank you so much for providing such a useful content. For any Norton Antivirus Support dial our toll free number +1-855-558-3999.

  9. Peach
  10. Roku

    Your article is very impressive I love to read this article. so keep writing and thanks for sharing with us.

Comments are closed.